The Duplicitous “Transparency” of Nathan Fielder's Brilliant “You Can See Everything”

Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s multi-faceted documentary creatively explores and weighs the importance of truth, accountability, and how conniving the human psyche can be

When I first saw the trailer for You Can See Everything, I was immediately intrigued. Especially seeing a comedian provocateur like Nathan Fielder attached to the project. Known for audacious TV shows like Nathan for You and The Rehearsal, when you think about it, this project seemed like a perfect intersection for both of those series.

Where Nathan for You delved into him coming up with ridiculous but “practical” fixes to help businesses succeed, and The Rehearsal routinely focused on losing yourself totally into a character to the point of potentially not recognizing yourself anymore – both can be said about the person or “character” (a theme the movie visits time and time again) of Elizabeth Holmes.

The first act of the movie specifically deals with Holmes and her final 34 days of freedom before reporting to prison to serve an 11-year, three-month prison sentence for defrauding investors of Theranos, a company she founded. She and her partner, Ramesh “Sunny” Balwani, were convicted of leading investors on to believe that a machine their company invented could diagnose diseases from a sample of blood from the prick of a finger. While Holmes claims in the documentary that it had the potential to do this eventually, it was clear the technology she claimed the product possessed was not totally accurately depicted at the time.

Which in turn, aptly leads into the theme of the documentary itself – Holmes, as well as our collective grasp of reality.

In her mind at least, she’s a victim in all of this, coerced by her partner and lover at the time Balwani into promoting their invention the way they did – and that his abusive and controlling ways disrupted her ability to rationalize things clearly.

In this film, she has moved on from Balwani and is currently dating Billy Evans, who comes across as a controlling narcissist who may very well be using Holmes, and the documentary crew itself, to profit financially on some level. The couple have two very young children together, which quietly operates as one of the more powerful parts of the film as Holmes wrestles with leaving her family behind for over a decade.

In one way, you feel for Holmes and her history of being persuaded and controlled by men, but at the same time you don’t believe that she’s a completely innocent victim in all of this.

Fielder effortlessly operates as a disruptor, chiming in and poking the bear with a seemingly innocent tone and line of questioning. The subjects swing anywhere from Evans being annoyed and grabbing a bowl of eggs that Holmes is mixing because he doesn’t like how she’s doing it, to sweeping topics like generational wealth and legacy on both families’ sides and if that could be playing a part in everything that is happening currently.

Throughout the documentary, Holmes remains steadfast that her invention works and that she did nothing wrong. While Fielder’s mission is to get something, anything close to a confession for her in the sense that maybe, just maybe, she has told a lie once in her life – and even that is a struggle.

Without revealing too much of the plot, suffice to say that around the halfway mark, this becomes a completely different movie in the best way possible and is something I have never really seen from a film before. Whatever occasional missteps in pacing (the first third could’ve been edited a tad), seem inconsequential to the grander scope of what the film accomplishes. Which is ultimately putting the weight of itself on the viewer and having you, like Fielder, have to try to rationalize what the actual truth of this story is.

It’s a film about the importance of communication and being extremely clear with your messaging, especially when you’re the CEO of the company and dealing with shareholders. But also, it’s a movie about how little nuances and body language cues could reveal that something larger is at play here. Both from a business and personal relationship perspective.

Really, this is a project about how we as human beings sometimes have a borderline obsession with trying to figure someone or something out. And how much can you really believe or trust in what somebody is saying, because you can’t get inside their head and fully know what they’re thinking.

But man, do Fielder and Oppenheim come as close as they possibly can to unwrapping it. While at the same time, you still have this feeling of being so far away from understanding the characters, as well as even Fielder himself in terms of potential affection for Holmes – and vice versa.

In the end, you feel like you have morphed into a version of Fielder himself. Which is usually his specialty, not the other way around.

For a movie titled You Can See Everything, you feel like you are seeing some things - but are still largely shielded from uncovering the everything that is the ultimate truth. And that kind of duality is what makes it an unassailable masterpiece.

Rating: **** out of ****

Next
Next

Steven Spielberg Happily Returns to His Alien-Roots with Disclosure Day